Sunday, March 8, 2009

如果英超這個球季實行6+5政策…

白禮達(Blatter)指他去年提出的6+5政策得到了費格遜的支持。突然忽發奇想,如果這個對現今球壇影響深遠的政策在今個球季實施,英超Big 5各隊的正選陣容會變成怎樣…

假設一: 6+5最終是指正選陣容必須有至少6個國藉為本土(即英國)球員,及最多5個非本土球員。
假設二: 英超Big 5沒有買人。
假設三: 由於部份球隊一隊本土球員不足夠,迫使他們從青年軍提升本土球員,又或者回收外借了的球員。

有*者指非本土球員

ManUtd
Rooney Berbetov*
Giggs Scholes Carrick Ronaldo*
Evra* Ferdidard Vidic* Brown
Van Der Sar*

Chelsea
Anelka* Sinclair
Kalou* Lampard Essien* JCole
ACole Terry Mancienne Bosingwa*
Cech*

Liverpool
Torres* Lindfield
Riera* Alonso* Gerrard Pennant
Aurelio* Hobbs Carragher Darby
Reina*

Aston Villa
Heskey Agbonlahor
AYoung Barry Reo-Coker Milner
Shorey Davies Knight LYoung
Taylor

Arsenal

Simpson VanPersie*
Wilshere Fabregas* Ramsey Walcott
Gibbs Toure* Gallas* Hoyte
Almunia*

結論一:利物浦的影響較阿仙奴大
結論二:曼聯的平均實力依然最強,因為還有幾個有實力本土球員未進入陣容中
結論三:阿士東維拉可以排出全部十一個都是本土球員的陣容,但實力跟現在正選相差不遠


SIX PLUS FIVE RULE
Blatter claims Fergie support over foreign quota

March 5, 2009

FIFA president Sepp Blatter claims he has the support of Sir Alex Ferguson for his six-plus-five principle, which would limit the number of foreign players on a team to five.

Blatter introduced the quota proposal last year, with the Premier League often the subject of his criticism for what he perceives to be a lack of homegrown players.

When the proposal was first introduced it was believed it would flounder on the European Union's insistence on free movement of labour around member states.

But following legal advice, Blatter is confident the system will be implemented to combat what he perceives to be the unhealthy domination of the Premier League.

He told BBC Radio 5 Live: ''We do not penalise the Premier League. The Premier League will still be well organised even if they start to have more players. Manchester United have started to have more players. In the starting XI the other day, they had four.

''I spoke with the leadership, including Sir Alex Ferguson, and he said it is a good solution because it will automatically not only give access to young players but it will also bring back a little of the expenses.

''We are now in a economic crisis.'' He added: ''I have my concerns because the PL is the strongest league in the world, definitely, and taking over in such a manner that other leagues have difficulties to match the Premier League.

''There is another factor. Where is the competition when two thirds or three quarters of participants play not to be first? They play not to be relegated.

''There is something wrong there. That's why we had the solution of the FIFA congress. It was always said it is against the European law, the freedom of circulation of workers.

''I feel positive now - more positive than I have been because of this legal advice from specialists in European law.''

Blatter is set to meet Premier League chief executive Richard Scudamore and added: ''What I want to try if not to persuade him is to influence him that a six-plus-five solution or five-plus-six will enhance the quality of his league.''

Blatter also expressed concern about the proliferation of foreign owners in English football, saying: ''The problem with ownership is definitely a risk. It is not the basis of football, but here we can do nothing.''

He sounded a note of warning to England's 2018 World Cup bid, hinting it may be hampered by a lack of a football figurehead.

''If you look at the technical infrastructure of the stadiums and the organisation of football matches on the level of up to 50,000 people then they are ready - but they are not the only one.

''The bidders will look for some promotion - not only by material but also from personalities. You have Beckham!

''I cannot interfere in this matter. But you know how bidding operations have been turned into success - there was somewhere always identified with a football personality.''

http://soccernet.espn.go.com/news/story?id=624997&cc=4716

4 comments:

  1. Is the 6+5 policy only applied to the Premier League?

    ReplyDelete
  2. It supposes to be applied to all football leagues of member countires of FIFA. However, any things about 6+5 is now on proposal stage only. We will see.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Ok.
    Thanks.
    That sounds a good policy anyways.

    ReplyDelete
  4. To protect local young players is a violation to the "idealism" of Free Market. Haha.

    I think it is important for England players and the national team in the long term.

    ReplyDelete